Saturday, November 14, 2020

The Check and Balance and Balance the Check: Church, Christianity and Leadership in the American Republic

 

The Check and Balance and Balance the Check: Church, Christianity and Leadership in the American Republic


Abstract

The separation of Church and State in the governmental structure of the United States is as conflicted as the connection of Church and State found in politics. While many of the Colonies used Christianity as a foundation element for support and legitimization of charters, there was a distinct transition in what role it should have between colonization, independence, and nationalization. However, in the growth of the nation, to support the true intention of what was to become a democratic republic meant to keep the Christian identity at its fore.

Excerpts from “Charters of the British Colonies in America” printed for John Almon

“…in propagating of Christian religion to such people as yet live in darkness and miserable ignorance of the true knowledge and worship of God” Virginia Charter (1601)

 “…invite the natives of that country to the knowledge and obedience of the only true God and Saviour of mankind and the Christian faith.” First Charter granted to the Colony of Massachusetts Bay (1644)

 “…reduce the savage nations, by gentle and just manners to the love of civil society and Christian religion” Pennsylvania Charter (1701)

 

Nearly every colony in their application for a charter held a clause recognizing the importance of Christianity its purpose. The various faiths that settled the lands of each colony, though often antagonistic in their relationships, were united in presenting the strength of Christian tenets in building the new land. These tenets built on not only the strength of Christianity for building community, but the idea of sustainability of community because of a clarity in direction and cause. For many, this clarity would be more than mortal actions but that of providence.

In each colony, whether overt in name or as unsaid practice leaned upon the religious freedom of Christianity. When the challenges and interdenominational disputes of what does it mean to be a colonist and Christian, pushed many of the settlements apart, the Puritans of Massachusetts versus the Quakers of Rhode Island or Pennsylvania, Virginia without a collective faith and mandating two services a day but still finding rebukes for not being a colony built on faith, there was still the identity of Christian in every defining action. Subsequently, as the soon to be new nation moved from colonies to independent states, the Constitution, like the Charters, held some of the language, as well as conflicts, between what it meant to be Christian in Government.

The Constitution often seen as the arbiter of separation of Church and State, not only from the first amendment, but the absence of christian language. Consequently, a letter to the Baptists of Danbury from Jefferson referring to the First Amendment as a wall between church and state. This gives argument that there should be no national church but each citizen had the right to freely choose the means by which they worshiped (Smith 2020, 176). However, this did not stop the implication for the will of Christianity in interpreting the actions and character of the men who would protect the freedoms or how they should be treated in the Nations most sacred document.

Quaker Dr. Benjamin Rush at the 1787 constitutional convention made clear the formation and success of the newly independent United States was “as much the work of a Divine Providence as any of the miracles recorded in the Old and New Testaments were the effects of a divine power (To Elias Boudinot on July 9, 1788 Letters of Benjamin Rush, 475).” In his writing of the Federalist Papers, James Madison, who was very private in his faith, stated his desire that a revered treatment of the Constitution would promote governmental stability. Thomas Jefferson, who like Madison did not openly espouse to a Christian denomination, used religious rhetoric to mock the constitutional durability sought by Madison, “Some men look at constitutions with sanctimonious reverence and deem them like the ark of the covenant, too sacred to be touched.” Because so many Americans put their faith in the Constitution (Friesen 2020, 57-58). Ultimately, this rhetorical division in viewing the importance of Christian character and faith in national leadership became less so in an election 50 years away.  

During the 1828 Presidential campaign, John Quincy Adams and Andrew Jackson were in a contest that divided their party and the country, but its clearest voice seem to come from the pulpit. Reverend Dr. Ezra Stiles Ely, Pastor of Philadelphia’s Old Pine Street Presbyterian Church argued in a July 4th 1827 sermon, heralded as the best campaign speech of the period, that if all true Christians should come together into what he called The Christian Party only Christians would lead the country because there were too many to ever be defeated. In addition, Ely stated the difference between the men was Jackson was a good Presbyterian, and his opponent Adams was a Unitarian and therefore not a Christian at all.(Dahl 1974, 140). However, the initial constitutional separation of Church and State was not lost on Ely.

Much like the diversity of Christianity shown in the earlier charters of the colonies, Ely understood there not one answer for faith in leadership. He did not want some constitutional religious test or mandate placed upon anyone seeking public office but the integrity of the christian over that of the party should be paramount (Stiles 1828, 5 - 9). Despite the divisive appearance of this argument, in one form or another it has played out in nearly every election campaign to follow.

The constant north star for the growth of the United States from Colonies to Nation has been the freedom supported by the people involved in self democratic rule. When examining the plea for the right to form a government for self to the language of the Constitution nearly 200 years later, for the founders, Christianity and Democracy are not only paramount but inseparable (Goodell 1849, iii). Certainly despite the evolution of the ironclad language that set every foundation of the identity of the United States, it would appear the promotion of Democracy requires and involves the promotion of Christianity.

 

Bibliography

Adams, Jasper, “The relation of Christianity to civil government in the United States : a sermon preached in St. Michael's Church, Charleston, February 13th, 1833, before the convention of the Protestant Episcopal Church of the Diocese of South-Carolina”, Gale CY0102787302, Library Huntington Library Charleston [S.C.]: A.E. Miller, 1833

Charters of the British Colonies in America. London, Printed for J. Almon.

Dahl, Curtis. “The Clergyman, the Hussy, and Old Hickory: Ezra Stiles Ely and the Peggy Eaton Affair.” Journal of Presbyterian History 52, no. 2 (1974): 137-155.

Ely, Ezra Stiles, “The duty of Christian freemen to elect Christian rulers : a discourse delivered on the fourth of July, 1827, in the Seventh Presbyterian Church, in Philadelphia” Sabin Collection Number 22382  Gale CY0105458206 Library Huntington Library, Philadelphia: W.F. Geddes, 1828

Friesen, Amanda. “American Constitutional Faith and the Politics of Hermeneutics.” Politics and religion. 13, no. 1 (March 2020): 57–88.

Goodell, William, “The democracy of Christianity, or, An analysis of the Bible and its doctrines in their relation to the principle of democracy” Sabin Collection Number 19488, Gale CY0107879348 Library American Antiquarian Society, New York:Cady & Burgess, 1849.

To Elias Boudinot on July 9, 1788. Letters of Benjamin Rush, L. H. Butterfield, ed., (Princeton, NJ: American Philosophical; Society, 1951), Vol. I.

Smith, L. Scott. "an Unsteady ‘wall of Separation’: A Few Considerations." Politikologija Religije 14, no. 1 (2020): 173 - 190