At a time when the fiscal challenges of the United States struck a disharmonious chord around the world, nearly every state stood in some form of challenge to house, feed and sustain its citizenry. However, one state seemed to be at the heart of the national challenge, not as a matter of organizational happenstance, but as the function of competing thoughts to rescue the economic system as a whole. Now fifty years after the Civil War, Mississippi was as divided and as ruptured as the nation herself and the first line of conflict was a bureaucratic accident.
The Federal Reserve Act of 1913 divided Mississippi into its own version of the North and South. The Atlanta Federal Reserve District held jurisdiction over the south while North Mississippi fell under the St. Louis Federal Reserve District. As the country was searching for clarity in rebounding from the challenges of the Great War, Mississippi had additional issues from declining cotton prices, a major boll weevil infestations, a devastating flood in 1927 followed by a significant drought and lumber companies abandoning many towns. In addition, with both Fed Houses creating a growing debt burden across the state, what came next mirrored the country in the worse ways.
As the signs of the Great Depression were finally being realized, many areas of the country sought answers. The fear of runs on the Banks held many areas hostage to stagnation at the worse time. Subsequently, the stagnation of the National Federal Reserve, and inexperienced choices, only compounded the issues. However, the actions of the two Federal Reserves splitting Mississippi, provided an immediate economic beaker for how the Country may have avoided the worse of the Depression era effects. The elements of the experiment set the stage for this perfect mixture of problems.
In a state where the extent of the previous accepted federal participation was the Post Office, there were many changes. The first of these can be seen in the correspondence of the constituents of Mississippi’s 6th District Congressman William M. Colmer who had recently been appointed Chair of the House Special Committee on Postwar Economic Policy and Planning. The requests, many from Veterans, ranged in requests for clothing, food reserves, and in a few cases direct cash payments or loans. These requests are seen across the Federal spectrum but Roosevelt’s New Deal and WPA were not as freely wanted in Mississippi.
Many of the letters to Colmer, while supporting Roosevelt’s efforts, did not trust the WPA to understand Mississippi. That there would be some work quickly followed by layoffs only made things more difficult. Interviews of surviving Slaves echoed this distrust. Freed Slave Jane Sutton from Harrison County, Mississippi,openly longed for the antebellum days: “I wish I could go back dar now. . . I’se telling you de truf, Miss, I’se havin’ a harder time now dan I ever had in slavery times.”It is the backdrop of these elements, the issues of the banks and local economy dependence are met head on by the actions of the Regional Federal Reserves and the policy battle for potential success is outlined.
To give or not to give became the question. As so many Reserves sought to fill the gap being left by the National Fed, Mississippi inadvertently became the test answer for a response with divergent policies in response to the banking panics. The Atlanta Federal Reserve stepped in to intervene and stabilize the banking systems in their purview. In doing so acted as an emergency last resort lender both extending credit to banks and providing an influx of liquidity to ailing financial institutions.
In contrast, the St. Louis Fed sought a nonintervention policy. Subsequently enacting a contraction policy of credit supply during the initial recession and limited any additional interventions ahead of potential banking panics. Data resulting from multiple studies show the bank survival rates and performance were far superior in the portion of Mississippi under the Atlanta Federal Reserve District jurisdiction, while the St. Louis banks failed catastrophically.
In Andrew Ross Sorkin’s text Too Big to Fail, Ben Bernanke, as played by Paul Giamatti in the movie has a consequential line in attempting to stave off the United States Recession of 2008: The depression may have started because of a stock market crash, but what hit the general economy was a disruption of credit. Average citizens unable to borrow money, to do anything. To buy a home, start a business, stock their shelves… Credit has the ability to build a modern economy, but lack of credit has the ability to destroy it, swiftly and absolutely.Though the reality of the infusion of cash and credit to the economy may have saved some of Mississippi’s economy in 1930 may be debated, the impact differential of the Atlanta Fed and the 2008 Fed actions cannot be ignored. Perhaps the way out was always there and a more decisive or experienced Federal Reserve in 1930 may have had a tool to mitigate the economic failures of that time.
Bibliography
Jalil, A. J. “Monetary Intervention really did Mitigate Banking Panics during the Great Depression: Evidence Along the Atlanta Federal Reserve District Border.” The Journal of Economic History 74, no. 1 (2014): 259-273.
Richardson, G. “Categories and Causes of Bank Distress during the Great Depression, 1929–1933: The Illiquidity Versus Insolvency Debate Revisited.” Explorations in Economic History 44, no. 4 (2007): 588-607.
Richardson, G. and William T. “Monetary Intervention Mitigated Banking Panics during the Great Depression: Quasi‐Experimental Evidence from a Federal Reserve District Border, 1929–1933.” The Journal of Political Economy 117, no. 6 (2009): 1031-1073.
Sorkin, Andrew Ross. Too big to fail: The inside story of how Wall Street and Washington fought to save the financial system--and themselves. Penguin, 2010.
Thompson, N. “Federal Reserve System Rising: The Expansion of Board Veto Authority on the Eve of the Great Depression.” New Political Economy 24, no. 4 (2019): 457-472.
Ziebarth, N. L. “Identifying the Effects of Bank Failures from a Natural Experiment in Mississippi during the Great Depression.” American Economic Journal. Macroeconomics 5, no. 1 (2013): 81-101.
“Depression and Hard Times in Mississippi: Letters.” Mississippi Now. http://www.mshistorynow.mdah.ms.gov/articles/221/index.php?s=extra&id=223
McMillen, N. R. “WPA Slave Narratives”Mississippi Now.
http://www.mshistorynow.mdah.ms.gov/articles/64/wpa-slave-narratives
No comments:
Post a Comment